Connect with us

World News

Surrogacy and the Global Debate: Perspectives and Reactions to Pope Francis’s Call for Ban

Annelise Sylta



Pope Francis made a bold and disputed call for the world to outlaw surrogacy, calling it “worst” and a serious disrespect to women’s and children’s values. He made this point in his yearly speech to Vatican diplomats about global issues. The Pope’s comments have started a worldwide debate over the morality, consequences, and what’s next for surrogacy.

Ethical Issues and Worldwide Feedback

  • Using Women in Need: The Pope pointed to the possible use of women in dire financial straits who may resort to becoming surrogates.
  • Children’s Worth and Rights: He expressed worries regarding the well-being and rights of surrogate-born kids, insisting on the protection of these young lives from being treated as merchandise.
  • Effect on LGBTQ+ Families: His remarks struck a chord with LGBTQ+ people who often see surrogacy as a way to start a family.

Understanding Surrogacy

A woman bears and delivers a baby for someone else through surrogacy, which raises a mix of ethical, legal, and intimate questions.

Why People Pick Surrogacy

  • Health Dangers: Some couples choose surrogacy when the pregnancy poses health hazards.
  • Battles with Infertility: Others look into surrogacy after struggling with infertility or suffering numerous miscarriages.
  • Becoming Parents for LGBTQ+: For many LGBTQ+ partners, surrogacy is an essential way to have kids.

The Rules Around Surrogacy

  • Different Laws: Surrogacy is banned in locations like Italy, but laws vary elsewhere, including U.S. states where paid surrogacy can be illegal.
  • Safeguarding Agreements: Those in favor argue that contracts in surrogacy are necessary to shield everyone involved, like the surrogate mother and the baby.

Advocates’ Perspectives

Supporters of surrogacy are upset and worried about what the Pope said.

Criticism of the Pope’s Comments

  • Individual Freedom: People in favor of surrogacy emphasize how vital it is for individuals to make their own choices about having kids.
  • Misunderstanding Surrogacy: Some think that the Pope’s words show he doesn’t get what surrogacy is all about.

Positive Aspects of Surrogacy

  • Creating Families: Many see surrogacy as a special way to help start families, especially for those who might not be able to otherwise.
  • Lasting Bonds: It’s common for surrogacy to lead to strong, enduring friendships among everyone involved.

Potential Consequences of a Global Ban

  • Affecting Families: If surrogacy were banned globally, it could be harder for numerous people, such as LGBTQ+ folks and infertile couples, to have kids.
  • Influence on Politics: The Pope’s stance might sway lawmakers and spark more conversation about reproductive freedoms.

Moving Forward: The Road Ahead

Policy and Legislation

  • Laws Might Change: Following the Pope’s statement, countries around the world may rethink their views on surrogacy and maybe change their laws.
  • Worldwide Talks: The push for a ban could lead to wider global talks and teamwork on how best to manage surrogacy laws.

The Role of the Catholic Church

  • Influencing Believers: The Catholic Church’s opinion can shape the thoughts and decisions of its over one billion followers across the globe.
  • Old vs. New: The Church struggles with modern issues, trying to keep its historical beliefs while dealing with today’s society.

Societal Implications

  • Changing Attitudes: The discussions around surrogacy are part of larger changes in how we view family and parenting norms.
  • Gender Inequality: Surrogacy can reinforce gender inequality. It often turns women’s bodies into commodities for hire.
  • Children’s Rights: Some folks are worried about the rights of kids born via surrogacy. They’re concerned about their welfare and identity.
  • Parenthood and Reproductive Rights: People also chat about the right to become parents and the options on the table for starting families.
  • Ethical Discourse: Loads of people will keep arguing about this stuff. It’s a big deal when it comes to morals, especially with all these new baby-making methods popping up everywhere.


So, the Pope wants to ban surrogacy all over the place. That opens a huge box of worms about what’s cool and what’s not when it comes to making babies and who gets to be a parent. There are lots of feelings flying around about women’s and kiddos’ rights. But then, there are also the people who can’t have babies any other way. This argument isn’t going anywhere anytime soon, and what folks think and what the law says is probably going to change because of it.

If you wanna dig deeper, check out what Reuters has got to say.

Image Source:, Attribution, via Wikimedia Commons

Anne Lise is an MBA graduate with a passion for doing business research and fashion reviews. She has been with Busybodytribune for over 4 years now, and is the lead editor for the magazine.